See Jane Run Weddings

She envies my collection of headbands (which I've built up over about 5 years). I received my first one from my older cousin Giselle when I was 13, so I feel it's fitting to give one to Madeléna.

I was thinking this, perhaps:

http://www.jenniferbehr.com/index.php?main=gall&gall=1&page=2

http://www.jenniferbehr.com/images/collection/1/gall_1_largest_9.jpg

in either "jet crystal" on black satin or "smoked crystal"on smoked satin.

OR

this:

http://www.jenniferbehr.com/index.php?main=gall&gall=1&thumb=19&page=3

http://www.jenniferbehr.com/images/collection/1/gall_1_largest_19.jpg

I think the first one's nicer, but I'm not sure which one would be better in the eyes of a 13-year-old.

Which do you think is best?